Welcome Guest [Log In] [Register]
We hope you enjoy your visit.


You're currently viewing our forum as a guest. This means you are limited to certain areas of the board and there are some features you can't use. If you join our community, you'll be able to access member-only sections, and use many member-only features such as customizing your profile, sending personal messages, and voting in polls. Registration is simple, fast, and completely free.


[http://s8.zetaboards.com/ratetheref/register//]Join our community![/url]


If you're already a member please log in to your account to access all of our features:

Username:   Password:
Add Reply
Rate the Ref Premier League Top 5 Referees; Post your vote here
Topic Started: Tuesday, 22. May 2018, 09:48 (2,656 Views)
edy
Member Avatar
Referee

The final ranking is announced. You can find it on the bottom of post 1.

A big thank you to everyone that has participated.
All I know is that I know nothing
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
AJB95
Member Avatar
Member
Think the biggest surprise is that mason is 12th! 😡
No ref, no game!
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
Ref Fan
No Avatar
Member
And thank you edy for proposing it and keeping tabs on the scores. Interesting and good fun,

As far as I can tell, only bfh1978 had all 5 names in the correct order of the final ranking.
Grahamexref had all 5 names but Marriner and Taylor in reverse sequence.

As for Mason, I suspect Hendo's 'tongue in cheek' vote and Hallux putting all the others second made up his 9 votes?!
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
edy
Member Avatar
Referee

Ref Fan
Monday, 4. June 2018, 18:08
As for Mason, I suspect Hendo's 'tongue in cheek' vote and Hallux putting all the others second made up his 9 votes?!
Exactly.
All I know is that I know nothing
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
readingfan
No Avatar


Thanks for your work on this Edy (and your work on Predict A Ref World Cup that I see has opened in another section of the board if others haven't seen it yet.)

A deserved win for Michael Oliver. I'd certainly agree that Atkinson, Marriner and Taylor have been the best of the rest, with not too much between them.

An excellent first season for Chris Kavanagh.
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
Hendo
No Avatar


edy
Monday, 4. June 2018, 18:18
Ref Fan
Monday, 4. June 2018, 18:08
As for Mason, I suspect Hendo's 'tongue in cheek' vote and Hallux putting all the others second made up his 9 votes?!
Exactly.
:innocent: ;)
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
Hendo
No Avatar


edy
Tuesday, 22. May 2018, 09:48
Now that the season is over, I think it's the best time to vote for the best PL referee of the season. As we did last season.

You just have to name your top 5 referees. Points will be awarded to referees as follows:

1st place - 5 points
2nd place - 4 points
3rd place - 3 points
4th place - 2 points
5th place - 1 point


Should you wish to edit your original post, please PM me with the change for my information.

The results will appear here, on the bottom of post #1.

This thread will close on Sunday 03rd June. The winners will be announced on Monday 04th June.

Final Ranking

Posted Image
Can we send a copy of this to Collina and co. so they know who the good old British on RTR clearly rate as our no. 1?
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
readingfan
No Avatar


Hendo
Wednesday, 6. June 2018, 12:30
edy
Tuesday, 22. May 2018, 09:48
Now that the season is over, I think it's the best time to vote for the best PL referee of the season. As we did last season.

You just have to name your top 5 referees. Points will be awarded to referees as follows:

1st place - 5 points
2nd place - 4 points
3rd place - 3 points
4th place - 2 points
5th place - 1 point


Should you wish to edit your original post, please PM me with the change for my information.

The results will appear here, on the bottom of post #1.

This thread will close on Sunday 03rd June. The winners will be announced on Monday 04th June.

Final Ranking

Posted Image
Can we send a copy of this to Collina and co. so they know who the good old British on RTR clearly rate as our no. 1?
I've sent one already to Mike Riley to advise that Lee Mason, Bobby Madley and Roger East are all considered to be in the top 2/3 of the Select Group ;)
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
plym_Nick
Member Avatar


readingfan
Wednesday, 6. June 2018, 14:01
Hendo
Wednesday, 6. June 2018, 12:30
edy
Tuesday, 22. May 2018, 09:48
Now that the season is over, I think it's the best time to vote for the best PL referee of the season. As we did last season.

You just have to name your top 5 referees. Points will be awarded to referees as follows:

1st place - 5 points
2nd place - 4 points
3rd place - 3 points
4th place - 2 points
5th place - 1 point


Should you wish to edit your original post, please PM me with the change for my information.

The results will appear here, on the bottom of post #1.

This thread will close on Sunday 03rd June. The winners will be announced on Monday 04th June.

Final Ranking

Posted Image
Can we send a copy of this to Collina and co. so they know who the good old British on RTR clearly rate as our no. 1?
I've sent one already to Mike Riley to advise that Lee Mason, Bobby Madley and Roger East are all considered to be in the top 2/3 of the Select Group ;)
Am i missing something? It clearly says oliver atkinson and marriner are considered our top 3 . Quite a fair reflection imo
It's nice to be important but much more important to be NICE ;)
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
edy
Member Avatar
Referee

If we were in Spain, Attwell and Probert would be demoted.
All I know is that I know nothing
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
RCG
No Avatar


That is read as a fraction 2 thirds i think
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
readingfan
No Avatar


edy
Wednesday, 6. June 2018, 16:55
If we were in Spain, Attwell and Probert would be demoted.
Presumably that system isn't dependent on forum votes? ;)

And yes 2/3 = two thirds.
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
Acme Thunderer
No Avatar


I was away and could not take part in this poll, so cannot comment in detail. However, as plym_Nick has suggested, the top three - Oliver, Atkinson and Marriner - seem to be a fair reflection of performance in the season just ended. My concern is that Lee Probert has come out bottom and Mike Dean is in the bottom third which I don't believe is a fair reflection. Perhaps this has something to do with the voting system which was (understandably) only for the top five, but both Lee and Mike have (imho) had steady if not spectacular seasons in the PL, and I would certainly not be thinking in terms of demoting either. Having said that, I am pleased that Chris Kavanagh has come out 5th which I believe is a fair reflection of an able new ref on the PL.
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
Hendo
No Avatar


plym_Nick
Wednesday, 6. June 2018, 16:29
readingfan
Wednesday, 6. June 2018, 14:01
Hendo
Wednesday, 6. June 2018, 12:30
edy
Tuesday, 22. May 2018, 09:48
Now that the season is over, I think it's the best time to vote for the best PL referee of the season. As we did last season.

You just have to name your top 5 referees. Points will be awarded to referees as follows:

1st place - 5 points
2nd place - 4 points
3rd place - 3 points
4th place - 2 points
5th place - 1 point


Should you wish to edit your original post, please PM me with the change for my information.

The results will appear here, on the bottom of post #1.

This thread will close on Sunday 03rd June. The winners will be announced on Monday 04th June.

Final Ranking

Posted Image
Can we send a copy of this to Collina and co. so they know who the good old British on RTR clearly rate as our no. 1?
I've sent one already to Mike Riley to advise that Lee Mason, Bobby Madley and Roger East are all considered to be in the top 2/3 of the Select Group ;)
Am i missing something? It clearly says oliver atkinson and marriner are considered our top 3 . Quite a fair reflection imo
I think the element of sarcasm from both edy and myself may have been overlooked here!
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
edy
Member Avatar
Referee

readingfan
Wednesday, 6. June 2018, 17:01
edy
Wednesday, 6. June 2018, 16:55
If we were in Spain, Attwell and Probert would be demoted.
Presumably that system isn't dependent on forum votes? ;)
:tu:
All I know is that I know nothing
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
readingfan
No Avatar


Hendo
Wednesday, 6. June 2018, 17:15
plym_Nick
Wednesday, 6. June 2018, 16:29
readingfan
Wednesday, 6. June 2018, 14:01
Hendo
Wednesday, 6. June 2018, 12:30
edy
Tuesday, 22. May 2018, 09:48
Now that the season is over, I think it's the best time to vote for the best PL referee of the season. As we did last season.

You just have to name your top 5 referees. Points will be awarded to referees as follows:

1st place - 5 points
2nd place - 4 points
3rd place - 3 points
4th place - 2 points
5th place - 1 point


Should you wish to edit your original post, please PM me with the change for my information.

The results will appear here, on the bottom of post #1.

This thread will close on Sunday 03rd June. The winners will be announced on Monday 04th June.

Final Ranking

Posted Image
Can we send a copy of this to Collina and co. so they know who the good old British on RTR clearly rate as our no. 1?
I've sent one already to Mike Riley to advise that Lee Mason, Bobby Madley and Roger East are all considered to be in the top 2/3 of the Select Group ;)
Am i missing something? It clearly says oliver atkinson and marriner are considered our top 3 . Quite a fair reflection imo
I think the element of sarcasm from both edy and myself may have been overlooked here!
I don't think it has - it wasn't exactly subtle! ;)
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
1 user reading this topic (1 Guest and 0 Anonymous)
« Previous Topic · General Discussion · Next Topic »
Add Reply

Free Domains Forwarding
RTR-ipad Theme by bmb