|
Sat 19th – Tue 22nd NOV 2016
|
|
Topic Started: Monday, 14. November 2016, 17:32 (3,921 Views)
|
|
TheThingFromLewes
|
Sunday, 20. November 2016, 11:34
Post #26
|
- Posts:
- 4,833
- Group:
- RTR Veteran
- Member
- #310
- Joined:
- Jul 31, 2007
- I support.....
- Fulham
|
I believe you are correct, although i have a nagging feeling it only applied to the keeper.
Deadman gave a laughable penalty for forest against Fulham a while back in similar circumstances. Consistency yes.. rank bad decision wrong!!
|
|
|
| |
|
Acme Thunderer
|
Sunday, 20. November 2016, 13:00
Post #27
|
- Posts:
- 3,830
- Group:
- RTR Veteran
- Member
- #1,496
- Joined:
- Apr 16, 2012
- I support.....
- Crystal Palace and Crewe (not necessarily in that order)
|
I have to say I thought both RC decisions were spot on although I also have to say I don't really know the current interpretation of 'denying a goal scoring opportunity' or whatever it is called now.
|
|
|
| |
|
MartinB
|
Tuesday, 22. November 2016, 14:52
Post #28
|
New Member
- Posts:
- 20
- Group:
- Members
- Member
- #2,209
- Joined:
- Oct 7, 2014
- Refereeing Level
- 7
- I support.....
- Shrewsbury Town
|
- Acme Thunderer
- Sunday, 20. November 2016, 13:00
I have to say I thought both RC decisions were spot on although I also have to say I don't really know the current interpretation of 'denying a goal scoring opportunity' or whatever it is called now. FA don't agree with you. First one overturned
|
|
|
| |
|
Acme Thunderer
|
Tuesday, 22. November 2016, 16:43
Post #29
|
- Posts:
- 3,830
- Group:
- RTR Veteran
- Member
- #1,496
- Joined:
- Apr 16, 2012
- I support.....
- Crystal Palace and Crewe (not necessarily in that order)
|
- Acme Thunderer
- Monday, 14. November 2016, 17:44
Crewe's turn to Kettle-watch, I might just go ;-) Nigel Miller travelling a lot further afield than Crewe this weekend. Lee Collins and Kevin Johnson out together at Yeovil, I'm sure the club and authorities will be hoping for no further injuries or accidents. I wish you well :hug: The jinx has struck again. Lee Collins and Kevin Johnson are not out tonight as the fixture at Yeovil has been postponed (BBC).
|
|
|
| |
|
Acme Thunderer
|
Tuesday, 22. November 2016, 18:07
Post #30
|
- Posts:
- 3,830
- Group:
- RTR Veteran
- Member
- #1,496
- Joined:
- Apr 16, 2012
- I support.....
- Crystal Palace and Crewe (not necessarily in that order)
|
- MartinB
- Tuesday, 22. November 2016, 14:52
- Acme Thunderer
- Sunday, 20. November 2016, 13:00
I have to say I thought both RC decisions were spot on although I also have to say I don't really know the current interpretation of 'denying a goal scoring opportunity' or whatever it is called now.
FA don't agree with you. First one overturned No problem from my point of view, but on what grounds was the first RC overturned I wonder? The foul looked very similar to the one that Roger East missed at Stoke last weekend. Are they saying that, even if Roger had given the penalty, he could only have yellow carded the offender? Bit of a nonsense in my view if it is.
|
|
|
| |
|
MartinB
|
Tuesday, 22. November 2016, 22:29
Post #31
|
New Member
- Posts:
- 20
- Group:
- Members
- Member
- #2,209
- Joined:
- Oct 7, 2014
- Refereeing Level
- 7
- I support.....
- Shrewsbury Town
|
- Acme Thunderer
- Tuesday, 22. November 2016, 18:07
- MartinB
- Tuesday, 22. November 2016, 14:52
- Acme Thunderer
- Sunday, 20. November 2016, 13:00
I have to say I thought both RC decisions were spot on although I also have to say I don't really know the current interpretation of 'denying a goal scoring opportunity' or whatever it is called now.
FA don't agree with you. First one overturned
No problem from my point of view, but on what grounds was the first RC overturned I wonder? The foul looked very similar to the one that Roger East missed at Stoke last weekend. Are they saying that, even if Roger had given the penalty, he could only have yellow carded the offender? Bit of a nonsense in my view if it is. Inside penalty area defender attempted to play the ball so only yellow card not red this season.
|
|
|
| |
|
nemesis
|
Wednesday, 23. November 2016, 11:57
Post #32
|
- Posts:
- 5,469
- Group:
- RTR Veteran
- Member
- #351
- Joined:
- Sep 17, 2007
|
- TheThingFromLewes
- Saturday, 19. November 2016, 01:07
- nemesis
- Saturday, 19. November 2016, 00:55
- TheThingFromLewes
- Friday, 18. November 2016, 22:53
- nemesis
- Friday, 18. November 2016, 22:01
- MichaelRef
- Friday, 18. November 2016, 17:25
Any late changes this week?
I'm personally keeping my fingers crossed for a "late change" on Tuesday.
Will you be casting your eye over Deadloss in person Nemesis? :D
I fear so, barring my hoped for late change!
We look forward to your usual insightful report afterwards!! Nothing much to report. After a controversial match on Saturday this must have been just the sort of game he'd hoped for with very little to challenge a referee. Tricky decisions were at a minimum with just one more foul than corner (the corner count being 15-1 in favour of the home team). Three yellow cards, none too contentious although he made a meal of the card showing ceremony calling one player back to him three times and another twice. On three occasions he belatedly signalled advantage when it was obvious he'd had no intention of giving a foul - I'm not keen on that. So all things considered a little irritating but no opportunity to show whether he'd got himself up to speed since Saturday with the new interpretations.
|
|
|
| |
|
edy
|
Wednesday, 23. November 2016, 12:40
Post #33
|
Referee
- Posts:
- 4,142
- Group:
- Administrator
- Member
- #931
- Joined:
- Sep 2, 2009
- Refereeing Level
- Obs.
- I support.....
- Panathinaikos FC, Leyton Orient FC
|
- Acme Thunderer
- Tuesday, 22. November 2016, 18:07
- MartinB
- Tuesday, 22. November 2016, 14:52
- Acme Thunderer
- Sunday, 20. November 2016, 13:00
I have to say I thought both RC decisions were spot on although I also have to say I don't really know the current interpretation of 'denying a goal scoring opportunity' or whatever it is called now.
FA don't agree with you. First one overturned
No problem from my point of view, but on what grounds was the first RC overturned I wonder? The foul looked very similar to the one that Roger East missed at Stoke last weekend. Are they saying that, even if Roger had given the penalty, he could only have yellow carded the offender? Bit of a nonsense in my view if it is. See here, AT.
http://www.theifab.com/#!/laws/fouls-and-misconduct/chapters/disciplinary-action
- Quote:
-
Denying a goal or an obvious goal-scoring opportunity
Where a player commits an offence against an opponent within their own penalty area which denies an opponent an obvious goal-scoring opportunity and the referee awards a penalty kick, the offending player is cautioned unless:
The offence is holding, pulling or pushing or The offending player does not attempt to play the ball or there is no possibility for the player making the challenge to play the ball or The offence is one which is punishable by a red card wherever it occurs on the field of play (e.g. serious foul play, violent conduct etc.)
In all the above circumstances the player is sent off.
|
|
All I know is that I know nothing
|
| |
|
Acme Thunderer
|
Wednesday, 23. November 2016, 14:58
Post #34
|
- Posts:
- 3,830
- Group:
- RTR Veteran
- Member
- #1,496
- Joined:
- Apr 16, 2012
- I support.....
- Crystal Palace and Crewe (not necessarily in that order)
|
- Acme Thunderer
- Monday, 14. November 2016, 17:44
Crewe's turn to Kettle-watch, I might just go ;-) Nigel Miller travelling a lot further afield than Crewe this weekend. Lee Collins and Kevin Johnson out together at Yeovil, I'm sure the club and authorities will be hoping for no further injuries or accidents. I wish you well :hug: I didn't get to Kettle-watch at Crewe v Morecambe last night but this from the Crewe Chronicle on-line:
"Garratt made a good stop from a Michael Rose free-kick on the stroke of half-time, awarded by referee Trevor Kettle in an awful first-half performance from the official".
Nothing more known I'm afraid.... :'(
|
|
|
| |
|
nemesis
|
Wednesday, 23. November 2016, 16:12
Post #35
|
- Posts:
- 5,469
- Group:
- RTR Veteran
- Member
- #351
- Joined:
- Sep 17, 2007
|
- Acme Thunderer
- Wednesday, 23. November 2016, 14:58
- Acme Thunderer
- Monday, 14. November 2016, 17:44
Crewe's turn to Kettle-watch, I might just go ;-) Nigel Miller travelling a lot further afield than Crewe this weekend. Lee Collins and Kevin Johnson out together at Yeovil, I'm sure the club and authorities will be hoping for no further injuries or accidents. I wish you well :hug:
I didn't get to Kettle-watch at Crewe v Morecambe last night but this from the Crewe Chronicle on-line: "Garratt made a good stop from a Michael Rose free-kick on the stroke of half-time, awarded by referee Trevor Kettle in an awful first-half performance from the official". Nothing more known I'm afraid.... :'(
Only the first half was awful ?
Sounds like one of his better games !
|
|
|
| |
|
Acme Thunderer
|
Wednesday, 23. November 2016, 17:11
Post #36
|
- Posts:
- 3,830
- Group:
- RTR Veteran
- Member
- #1,496
- Joined:
- Apr 16, 2012
- I support.....
- Crystal Palace and Crewe (not necessarily in that order)
|
- nemesis
- Wednesday, 23. November 2016, 16:12
- Acme Thunderer
- Wednesday, 23. November 2016, 14:58
- Acme Thunderer
- Monday, 14. November 2016, 17:44
Crewe's turn to Kettle-watch, I might just go ;-) Nigel Miller travelling a lot further afield than Crewe this weekend. Lee Collins and Kevin Johnson out together at Yeovil, I'm sure the club and authorities will be hoping for no further injuries or accidents. I wish you well :hug:
I didn't get to Kettle-watch at Crewe v Morecambe last night but this from the Crewe Chronicle on-line: "Garratt made a good stop from a Michael Rose free-kick on the stroke of half-time, awarded by referee Trevor Kettle in an awful first-half performance from the official". Nothing more known I'm afraid.... :'(
Only the first half was awful ? Sounds like one of his better games ! :cheer: :clap:
Thank edy for clarifying the law on fouls in the penalty area which explains why the RC issued by Deadman was overturned
|
|
|
| |
|
TheThingFromLewes
|
Wednesday, 23. November 2016, 18:16
Post #37
|
- Posts:
- 4,833
- Group:
- RTR Veteran
- Member
- #310
- Joined:
- Jul 31, 2007
- I support.....
- Fulham
|
- nemesis
- Wednesday, 23. November 2016, 16:12
- Acme Thunderer
- Wednesday, 23. November 2016, 14:58
- Acme Thunderer
- Monday, 14. November 2016, 17:44
Crewe's turn to Kettle-watch, I might just go ;-) Nigel Miller travelling a lot further afield than Crewe this weekend. Lee Collins and Kevin Johnson out together at Yeovil, I'm sure the club and authorities will be hoping for no further injuries or accidents. I wish you well :hug:
I didn't get to Kettle-watch at Crewe v Morecambe last night but this from the Crewe Chronicle on-line: "Garratt made a good stop from a Michael Rose free-kick on the stroke of half-time, awarded by referee Trevor Kettle in an awful first-half performance from the official". Nothing more known I'm afraid.... :'(
Only the first half was awful ? Sounds like one of his better games ! I was even more shocked to see Kettle kept a clean sheet until 70 minutes!!!!
|
|
|
| |
| 1 user reading this topic (1 Guest and 0 Anonymous)
|